Teachers Unions Must Stop Standing With Republicans Against Closing the Equity 'Loophole' in Title I Funding

Federal law requires school districts receiving Title I dollars to demonstrate that they are providing “comparable” education services between high-poverty and low-poverty schools. That is supposed to make public school funding equal, at least in terms of resourcing students at the school level, but there is one yawning loophole: what a district charges schools for teacher positions is done wholly without regard for equity. How? A poor school with 10 teachers earning  an annual salary of $40,000 pays the same cost for those 10 teachers as a richer, Whiter school pays for its teachers who earn $80,000. The school sites pay an “average teacher salary” rather than the actual teacher salary. That’s a great deal for the wealthier school. Not so for the poorer school. Unions defend the practice because teachers cherish their contractual rights around bidding, transferring or being assigned to schools based on hard-earned seniority systems. It’s a professional right to “shop” for schools with more desirable student populations (read: White and less challenging) as they gain years of experience and become more expensive to their school districts. It’s sad, but this is one intersection when unions prioritize the personal interests of their members over the critical interests of disadvantaged communities. When Randi Weingarten, president of the American Federation of Teachers (AFT), testified before Congress on the issue she defended the status quo. It put her and the AFT shoulder to shoulder with Republicans, indifferent to equity, and out of stride with civil rights groups who have called out the unfairness of the equity loophole. That should call into question all of the racial theater the AFT participates in, and all of their cleverly worded press statements saying they “stand in solidarity” with communities of color. When the rubber hits the road they stand with their mostly White workforce, and the Republicans who have recently taken up their cause.